Tag-Archive for » masculinity «

I don’t know, and I’m not paralyzingly afraid to admit that.

I don’t know why I’ve been villifying men lately.  It isn’t fair to the good ones.

I don’t know why I’ve been perceiving them as threatening.

But then none of that is completely true.  I do know.  I know why I’ve been vilifying men.  I know why I’ve been interpreting their faces as threatening.  It’s not like any of it happens consciously—it’s always in retrospect when something suddenly triggers the memory—but it doesn’t change the fact that these thoughts are occurring to me.

Here, I can hear Sam telling me I need to stop taking my thoughts so seriously.

Unfortunately, that’s not really something I’m good at doing, nor do I know how to train myself to do that.

Bear with me while I try to break this idea down to something I can better understand:

I shouldn’t take my thoughts so seriously.  The “so” implies that I can take them seriously, but I shouldn’t take them as seriously as I do.  So I guess that means I should loosen up.  I shouldn’t take myself so seriously.  After all, I am my thoughts, aren’t I?

Yes, of course, I am.  But that doesn’t take into account the fact that we are, other than a series of chemical reactions, a compilation of experiences—engagements with the world.  That necessarily complicates the idea that I am my thoughts.  In the words of Chuck Palahniuk, “Nothing of me is original.  I am the combined effort of everybody I’ve ever known.”  If you break down what I am, given the information I’ve stated here, I am an effect of my experiences in the the world.  So, if I am my thoughts and I am an effect of the world, than my thoughts are just as I am.

Now, accepting that, and applying that belief to my efforts to comprehend how I can not take my thoughts seriously, that means I can’t take the effect my experiences have had on me seriously.

I can’t do that.  I can’t ignore my experiences.  Every day, every hour, I do something that was completely motivated by the sexual abuse and assaults I’ve survived.  How can I not take that seriously?!  That—that would be letting them win.  Yesterday, I wondered, have I been surviving to only know more pain?  I wondered whether men had already taken the best parts of me.  And I really felt that they had won.  I was dead.

Today, I can say, with perhaps a clearer mind, that if I stop giving my thoughts the attention and respect they deserve, I’ll once more become a victim.  The Andys each convinced me very thoroughly that my thoughts were not worth attention nor respect, that I wasn’t worth those things .  So, if I don’t give that notice to myself, then I’m internalizing their abuse, thereby hurting myself in deeper ways than they ever could.  I would be setting myself up for another abusive situation.

Like I’ve been doing by acting so irresponsibly lately.  I can now see the last two to three weeks have been as emotionally hectic as they have been because I’ve been hurting myself.  That forces me to consider why I’m trying to hurt myself, but the reasons are so numerous—

No.  It all condenses into one cause: the abuses I’ve endured.  People have hurt me.  How can I not take that seriously?

—That makes me feel a little less afraid right now: I take myself seriously.  It implies I have a sense of self-worth, no?

16
Nov

Originally posted here, the following [with little editing] was in response to a friend’s comment.  I’ve re-posted it here to bring attention to this major part of my trauma I’ve been trying so desperately to ignore: men as a whole.

Every day, I struggle to see men as fellow victims. Intellectually, I know they are. I know the patriarchy has claimed them as it’s claimed us.

But then the two men I respect most in the world tease me for the aches and pains my constant anxiety have caused. “It was all harmless kidding,” I tell myself, “and it is kind of comical. I’m always whining.”

A long list of self-deprecations are proven true by their laughter.

I—I hate to admit it, but I feel very much like you do. I still sometimes think, “aw, look at that guy with his kid.” That, however, is quickly subsumed by images of him molesting her.

I’m probably naive, but I just can’t embrace that image, yet. I can’t think of all men that way. I feel that, for me, and I only speak for myself, I would be giving into the trauma and condemning myself to this fractured reality.

I know. I’m a fool for hoping. They keep beating me, and I keep licking their hand. But, as I see it, if I give up on men, I give up on women, too. It’s the nature of a binary. To that point, I’ve dated women. Their good intentions are equally worthless. Even the ones you don’t so much as kiss will caress your soul as they lead you toward their parapet.

No. Forget what I said. My argument is flawed. None of those women damaged me for years: stole into my mind, ripped apart my anatomy, and irrevocably harmed my sexuality.

You caught me, bradamant. I’m having some difficulty accepting my feelings against men. I know it doesn’t end. I want to say there are exceptions, but every man I’ve thought was an exception has proven to actually be damaging in a way so subtle, his damage is more perverse than the last one’s.

But I’m afraid to hate men, bradamant. I’m afraid to leave them forever. I fear I would be letting the Andys win.

Not letting them win is the only thing that drives me.

Oh, God! That’s an ugly realization! They’re at the essence of my every motivation. They define me.

Have they already won?

Brw says I hate men. He says I haven’t even begun to deal with how much I hate men.

At first, I staunchly argued I didn’t. But within the minute, I was crumpled on the couch in tears. He’s right. I hate men. I hate them with a passion I’m uncomfortable with. I hate them like I hate Andy, because to me, most of them are Andy. Why else create this umbrella figure, Andy Humanstein, if not to tear away any distinction between between one man and another? Certainly, I don’t call all men Andy—not Sang or my boyfriend or any number of men in my life—but I have to admit, I fear them all. And fear breeds hatred.

I fear them because they’re stronger than me. They can overpower me. And they have. I fear them because they have peni that can penetrate and hurt me, and they have—several times. I fear them because they demean me in ways no woman ever could, and many wouldn’t even think to. I fear them because I was taught to build my self-esteem on their desire for me, and I still often do. I fear them because they’ve so often used that to their advantage.

It’s not all men, but it’s enough of them to keep me frightened.

Even the good ones, even my boyfriend, thinks and says things that repulse me or are meant to wound me. They demean so thoughtlessly, so quickly, with this “walk it off” mentality that minimizes the pain they just inflicted, minimizes the nature of their action. And the blame always comes back on me. “Well, then, you shouldn’t have….”

I’m tired of them. I love my boyfriend. I do. But every day is accompanied by an emotional wound that festers into resentment and anger. With him, at least these wounds are resolved, they aren’t deep, I can deal with them. Yet he also reinforces some of the opinions I have of men, opinions I had hoped he would debunk. I think, if the nice guy says these awful things, too—if the nice guy also makes these backhanded comments, emotional slaps across my face to remind me I’m weaker than him—how am I supposed to regain confidence in men?

I’m trying, here. I’m really trying to see the good in them. And I understand that women can be just as cruel. I know it from my experiences with Clara, with Nyte, with friends and partners alike. But not like men. Those women could not possibly hurt me like men have, in the ways men have. They don’t give me nightmares. They haven’t forced me against my will, nor would they dream of it. They never sent me to the hospital. When I argue with a woman, and I ask to have a clean fight, I get one. I don’t like to yell, so there we sit, talking and listening. When I tell that to Brw, he waits for a weak moment to attack. He continues to attack, locates my insecurity, and he says the words he knows will defeat me. For him, it’s always about winning. For women, at least in my experience, it’s always been about understanding, learning, coming to an agreement. There’s nothing to fear in compromise, but when I ask for it of Brw, he sees it as a personal assault against his very way of being. It’s exhausting. Emotionally, psychologically, he wears me down, and he knows it.

So, yeah, I hate men. I don’t wish them ill. I just wish they wouldn’t be so cruel, so mean, so underhanded and play such dirty games. Why can’t we be honest with each other? Why must you hurt me? What satisfaction is there in damaging our relationship, whatever its nature might be? Is winning really more important than me? Do I mean so little as a human being?

I understand it’s socialization. I know it’s this culture and this patriarchy. But goddamn it, we’re thinking beings. We’ve mastered communication. Let’s use it. Let’s talk. Let’s not hurt each other in these purposeful ways that only break down the human connection. No? It can’t be done? Then don’t wonder why I hate you. Don’t wonder why I cower from you. I don’t want to hear about how much it hurts you when you see me get scared of you. Of course, I am. You may not be a monster. You may not force me to gratify your desires. But when you hurt me, when you say these things that size me down because you—you—are just as scared as I am, you rape me, too. Don’t ever think that a penis is the only way to do it. Don’t ever think you don’t have the potential to become an Andy very quickly, or that you’re better than him. You’re not. You do other things. You hurt me and others in other ways.

So please, please, let’s sit down calmly, and let’s talk. I don’t want to hate you anymore. I don’t want to feel dirty or little anymore. I just want to be okay. Okay? Can we just be okay with each other? Please? I just want to be okay.